Zimpapers Logo

Arthur Marara-Point Blank

(Continued from last week)

Have you ever found yourself in a situation where your efforts to solve a problem ended up causing more harm than good? This phenomenon is known as the Cobra Effect, where a well-intentioned solution leads to unintended and negative outcomes.

There are few more examples illustrating the cobra effect in action:

Crime rate – New York (1970s)

During the 1970s, New York City adopted a policy that incentivised police officers with rewards for each arrest made. While this initiative led to a noticeable increase in arrests, it also fostered an environment where police officers focused more on maximising arrests to earn rewards rather than on preventing crime.

Consequently, innocent individuals faced unwarranted harassment, and the primary goal of reducing crime was overshadowed by the pursuit of monetary incentives.

Fertility rate example, India

 In an attempt to address the burgeoning population, the government of India initiated a campaign offering incentives to individuals opting for sterilisation procedures. This well-intentioned incentive programme aimed to curb population growth. However, some healthcare providers began performing unnecessary sterilisations to benefit from the rewards, disregarding the ethical implications and medical necessity. 

The result was numerous women suffering from post-surgery complications or, tragically, losing their lives due to this mismanaged incentive scheme.

These instances underscore the critical importance of thoroughly evaluating the potential ramifications and unintended consequences of policies and incentives before implementation. 

The Cobra Effect serves as a stark reminder that seemingly straightforward solutions can often lead to unforeseen outcomes, emphasising the necessity of holistic and forward-thinking approaches to problem-solving.

Beyond public policies, the Cobra Effect is a concept that resonates in daily decision-making scenarios. Often, individuals and organisations overlook or disregard the potential unintended consequences that may result from their actions, leading to outcomes that are counterproductive to their original intentions.

This history of well-intentioned policies backfiring serves as a poignant reminder of the importance of thorough deliberation and foresight in decision-making to avoid inadvertently worsening a situation.

Cobra Effect in modern day business

In the business world, the Cobra Effect can manifest in various forms, often stemming from unintended consequences of well-intentioned strategies or policies. Some common examples include:

Sales quotas

 In an effort to drive sales and motivate employees, companies may establish aggressive sales quotas and commission structures. However, this may inadvertently lead to unethical practices such as mis-selling, overly aggressive sales tactics, or the manipulation of sales data to meet targets, ultimately compromising customer trust and company reputation.

Cost reduction measures

 When companies implement cost-cutting initiatives to improve profitability, it can result in employees feeling undervalued or overworked. This may lead to reduced morale, employee turnover, and decreased productivity, offsetting the intended financial gains.

Performance metrics

Setting rigid performance metrics and Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) without proper consideration of the broader impact can incentivise employees to prioritise meeting those metrics at the expense of overall business objectives. This tunnel vision can hinder innovation, collaboration, and long-term growth.

Customer loyalty programmes

 While loyalty programmes are intended to retain customers and drive repeat business, they may inadvertently encourage transactional behaviour rather than fostering genuine customer loyalty. Customers may engage solely to earn rewards, leading to a high churn rate and decreased profitability.

Outsourcing

Companies often outsource services to reduce costs and improve efficiency. However, if not managed effectively, outsourcing can result in quality issues, communication challenges, and loss of organisational knowledge, outweighing the anticipated benefits of cost savings.

Mergers and acquisitions

 Mergers and acquisitions are commonly pursued to achieve synergies, expand market share, or enhance competitiveness. However, if integration processes are mishandled or cultural differences are overlooked, it can lead to operational disruptions, employee disengagement, and reduced shareholder value.

Price Promotions

Offering frequent discounts or promotions to drive short-term sales may attract price-sensitive customers who only purchase during promotions. This can erode brand loyalty, diminish perceived value, and create a dependency on discounts, impacting long-term revenue.

Arthur Marara is a corporate law attorney, keynote speaker, peak performance and corporate strategy speaker. With his delightful humour, raw energy, and wealth of life experiences, he captivates audiences and inspires them to unlock their full potential. Through his engaging talks and workshops, he imparts invaluable insights and practical strategies that empower individuals to lead with confidence and make a lasting impact. 

Arthur is the author of “Toys for Adults” a thought provoking book on entrepreneurship, and “No one is Coming” a book that seeks to equip leaders to take charge. 

Feedback :[email protected] or Visit his website www.arthurmarara.com or contact him on +263772467255 (Calls) or WhatsApp: +263780055152.